When Students Choose Resolution: Powerful Lessons from McCaskey’s Peer Mediators

Mar 16, 2026 | Education, Events, Making Peace, Mediation, News, Volunteers

Conflict is inevitable but violence and disconnection don’t have to be. At a recent Advoz donor event hosted at McCaskey High School, students took center stage to share how peer mediation is reshaping the way conflict is addressed, understood, and resolved within their school community. 

Peer mediators spoke candidly about why they chose this role: to be a safe listener, to prevent violence, and to help their peers feel seen and respected. Again and again, students emphasized how difficult it can be to open up to adults, and how powerful it is to talk with someone who understands their world. Peer mediation, they explained, creates a calming, consent-based space where students feel welcome to share honestly. 

Through their training, mediators learned skills that extend far beyond the mediation room. Active listening, patience, emotional awareness, and accountability now shape how they navigate everyday life at school, at work, and in their relationships. One student shared that, “one thing being a mediator taught me is that sometimes people just need someone to listen to them. They don’t always need advice.” They reflected on learning to listen, recognizing different perspectives, and becoming more mindful of body language and tone.  

One of the most powerful themes of the event was student-initiated mediation. During these optional processes, final agreements are always made by students regardless of whether they were initiated by teachers or by peers. The mediators noted, however, that when students request mediation themselves, rather than being recommended by teachers, the process is more genuine and effective. One student noted that, “because the agreements are made by the students themselves, it feels more like a want than a force. That’s what makes people actually follow through.” Mediators shared moving stories of conflicts that ended in apologies, accountability, and even renewed friendships largely because students were empowered with tools to do conflict well. 

What sustains these young leaders through challenging moments is care, both for themselves and for others. They spoke about self-care, reflection, and the belief that showing up with presence and respect can change outcomes. 

Their message was clear: when students are trusted and supported, they choose connection over conflict, and the entire community is stronger for it. 

No Results Found

The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.

No Results Found

The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.

Read More from the Advoz Blog

Advoz’s 2018-2019 Annual Report: Core Concentration

Restorative Justice Victim Offender Conferencing cases continue to be about half of Advoz's caseload, primarily referred from Lancaster County's Juvenile Probation and Juvenile Court. Your dollars were a long-term community investment as we concentrated on core...

A Voice of Welcome: Addrienne Whitfield

A Voice of Welcome: Addrienne Whitfield

Advoz has a new friendly voice who could be answering your phone call; Addrienne Whitfield began in September as Advoz’s administrative assistant. She joins the organization from the travel and service industry where she brings extensive customer service experience...

Cutting through the Buzz: Facilitating Summer Learning

Cutting through the Buzz: Facilitating Summer Learning

By Jake Rauchberg There was a buzz in the room. Between my excitement for my first Advoz program and the white noise engulfing the space, I could barely hear myself think. But it wasn’t the sort of buzz that you normally hear when you walk into a church on the...

Peacebuilding across Generations: Elliot Martin

Peacebuilding across Generations: Elliot Martin

By Skyler Gibbon, Advoz Intern Hearing his father’s stories around the dinner table inspired Elliot Martin to get involved with Advoz. “It sounded beautiful. There are really important principles of restorative justice. Needing to address the harm in conflict is...

Spreading Peace Across Generations: Tim Martin

Spreading Peace Across Generations: Tim Martin

By Skyler Gibbon, Advoz Intern Meet Tim and Elliot Martin, a father son duo volunteering with Advoz. After years of conversations about cases around the dinner table, Elliot decided to try it out for himself this spring. He joined the victim offender conferencing...

Calling All Volunteer (Peace Makers)

There are many ways one can contribute their time and skills to this work at Advoz! Calls continue into our office: conflicts, crimes, broken relationships. Can you answer this call for peacemakers in our community? We are looking for volunteers to help community...

Welcome Krista Rittenhouse

Welcome Krista Rittenhouse

Krista Rittenhouse got involved with Advoz training and volunteering in our Restorative Justice Conferencing program this spring. But she went above and beyond the call of duty by successfully reaching out to dozens of people impacted by crime and violations on the...

Making Peace ~ Poetry & Practice

Making Peace ~ Poetry & Practice

Each month, youth and parents have a chance to practice being peacemakers in their own world, family, school, friends, community. It's a class called Making Peace and the youth, often referred by Youth Aid Panels from school fights and other first-time incidents,...